Happy Birthday, Martin!!!
Pawlene is still recovering from last week’s bath, and has kindly agreed to let me use this space for a rant that has been slowly building for the past 2 weeks. 2 weeks and 2 days, to be exact.
I hate the PATH. For the uninitiated, the PATH or “Port Authority Trans-Hudson Corporation” train, is the fastest, cheapest way to get from Manhattan to New Jersey. It’s an underground subway system, much like the New York City subway, that travels under the Hudson River. Now, I *adore* the subway – it is often faster than taking a cab, I love the folks who sing and play music in the stations and sometimes on the trains, I love how frequently it runs, I love the choreographed chaos at the big stations like 42nd Street where thousands of New Yorkers expertly thread through and around each other as they rush forward to make their transfers. I really love those infrequent conductors who personalize their spiel with an addendum to their announcement: “Now arriving 34th Street: Penn Station, Madison Square Garden, Home of the World-Famous Knicks!” I even love the rats – I once counted 9 separate rats frolicking and foraging between the rails at Penn Station. Rat-spotting is my favorite past time while waiting for a train. But I digress. This rant is about the PATH.
After just a few days of taking the PATH train consistently to and from work and various Manhattan-based appointments, I noticed a steadily building feeling of resentment and distaste for my daily commute. I decided to analyze the problem, briefly querying Martin, who also hates the PATH (to the point of being willing to spend over 3 times as much to take the ferry). No, it’s not just because the PATH goes to New Jersey, or because it happens to carry us to our j-o-bs. In order to figure out why I hate the PATH so much, I decided to compare the PATH with my beloved subway. What is the difference between the PATH and the subway?
1. The Stairs vs. The Conveyor BeltTo access any subway station in New York City, you must use stairs. Yes, of course there are elevators for those who need them, but really, everyone uses the stairs. Sometimes there are a LOT of stairs, but there are always landings to rest on, large expanses to cross in between, turns to break it up. Sometimes you will have to go down the stairs, only to go up more stairs (and down still MORE stairs) before your reach your platform. This may seem inconvenient, but it’s great exercise, and it’s all part of the commuter ballet and the novelty of utilizing a mode of public transportation that has been in existence for over 100 years.
In contrast, when you reach the Exchange Place station in New Jersey (re-modeled in 2003), where Martin and I both exit the PATH train, you have a choice of taking either the elevator or the escalator. There is one set of stairs, but it is the longest stretch of unbroken stairway I have ever seen. It’s daunting just to look at, and this is coming from someone who used to choose to get up at 0 dark 30 every Tuesday just to run up and down these things in NW Portland. And so we go from horizontally speeding mechanized metal box to vertically elevating mechanized metal box. This has the unnerving effect of being completely out of control of one’s own destiny. The escalator is slightly better, because we can choose to take the passing lane and hike up the escalator, but I still get that “lump of meat on a conveyor belt” feeling. It’s very futuristic, I suppose, to just shift yourself from one moving box or belt to another until you reach your destination with very little actual effort on your part, but I like the novelty of moving at my own speed up and down stairs. The feeling of insignificance is intensified when we leave the station and walk along the waterfront to our respective workplaces because the scale of the buildings in waterfront Jersey City is designed to impress (they are Powerful Financial Institutions), and make you feel small. Not to mention the TWO depressing memorials we pass in less than a quarter of a mile. One, honoring the victims of the Katyn Massacre (a Polish massacre by Soviet troops in 1940)
dramatically and hugely depicts a man in the moment just after he has been stabbed in the back by a bayonet. But Jersey City itself is
another rant.
2. The ClienteleThe most noticeable difference between the New York City Subway and the PATH is the clientele. Between Jersey and New York, you get pretty much one type – professional commuters, en route to or from their white-collar office jobs. Men with short hair cuts in blue shirts and khakis, women in flip flops with enormous purses. No harmonizing crooners. No pan handlers with tales of woe. No smelly bums [Ok, Martin just contested this myth with a truly terrifying tale of Stench]. But definitely no hipsters. And no fashionistas to remind us why we are grateful that the 80s are over. Again, this may sound like a good thing to many of you, but I miss the eye candy. The main reason for the homogenous clientele is the limitations of the PATH train routes. It’s only 13.8 miles and it only goes to 4 places, and you can’t get off and walk if you don’t like it, unless you’ve brought your SCUBA gear. The NYC Subway, on the other hand, is comprised of 842 miles of track. So many places to go! The possibilities and permutations are endless…and YOU are in control of how you reach your destiny. More than on the PATH at any rate.
3. The StationsThere are two kinds of stations on the PATH – large, modern, recently re-modeled stations (Exchange Place) and tiny, cramped, ancient stations. The ancient stations in New York City make me think of either bygone eras when people actually cared about (and for) their surroundings (beautiful tile mosaics) or the fact that nobody really knows where all of these tunnels go, how they connect, or what is living in them (bizarre stalactites of some unidentified calcified mineral leaking from the roof, The Mole People by Jennifer Toth). The older PATH stations, in contrast, just make me vaguely claustrophobic and depressed. I always feel like I’m going to hit my head on the ceiling in the Pavonia station, and then I start to wonder what exactly is coating the ceiling – whether it was an intentional “granite-like” texture that some mis-guided interior designer decided to spray on, or if it’s just grime that has gotten caught in an impossible-to-clean layer of asbestos. The “décor” is invariably generic and utterly without charm or aesthetic value. And, there are no trash cans. The PATH stations were clearly not designed with the customer in mind.
4. The WindAny rant about the PATH would be incomplete without mention of the winds that rush forcefully through every station. It has something to do with the design of the tunnels. In the New York City subway system, there are tunnels upon tunnels leading and merging in and out of other tunnels. The strange effect that this configuration produces is that of “leftover air”. In the underground, the temperature is almost always what it what above ground the day before. So, if it was 90 degrees in Manhattan on Monday and 70 degrees on Tuesday, it will be 90 degrees in the subway station on Tuesday and 70 degrees on Wednesday.
PATH tunnels are designed differently, and produce an entirely different effect. According to the badly written
Wikipedia entry for the PATH: “The tunnels are separate for each track, which enables a better ventilation by so-called piston effect. When a train passes through the tunnel it pushes out the air in front of it toward the closest ventilation shaft it front, and "sucks-in" the air to the tunnel from the closest ventilation shaft behind it.” At any rate, the effect is that of standing in (or fighting against, if you are trying to leave the station) a gale-force windstorm while you are waiting for your train. Try that in a dress, with long hair, wearing sticky lipstick, and attempting to read the paper. It’s hard, and creates additional undue stress in my commute.
In SumI love New York City because I can choose to do, see, eat, and experience (almost) anything I want, whenever I want. I value diversity and freedom of choice. It’s why I don’t go to Starbucks (yet another rant). The PATH train reduces my options in many ways, and forces me to travel in a claustrophobic, boring, uncomfortable little box instead of meandering through the streets, admiring the wonders and humanity of this amazing City on my way to work in another boring little box.